Page 7 - BRIDGES - ISSUE 7
P. 7

Cross Cultural Stereotypes                                      say that all these cases are realized in
                                                                               practice, but they exist as a potential
               in Foreign Language Teaching                                    which can be realized, especially in

              ««                                                               timesof conflict. The issueisverycom-
                                                                               plex, and is not only the matter of for-
               undertaken or imported from other  stereotyped representations present  eign language teaching and learning.
               cultures/civilizations and/orliterature.  in the learner’s country regarding the  It has to bedealt with within theframe-
               A good example of the latter is the  foreign country. To be able to do it,  work of the educational system of a
               saying Greek gifts’, which in this or  the learner has to acquire socio-cul-  particular country.In what is tofollow
                    '
               that mode entered the vocabulary of  turalcompetencewhich is transferable  I shall try to draw attention to two
               many languages thanks to Virgil  to other cultural systems, independ-  burning issues needing immediate at-
               (Aeneid II,48-Timeo Danaoset dona  ent of the contents of a specific FLL.  tention:
               ferentes).                      These ideas have been successfully  a) The culture Y does not have a par-
                                               implemented in a new generation of  ticularly developed stereotype about
              Theymayinclude factual information  textbooks. The programme also en-  X’s culture, and then this culture is
               about a country,circumstances under  courages mobility,experiential learn-  seen through the general stereotype
              which a particular nation lives,as well  ing through ethnographicproject work  of thesuperordinate category towhich
              They also warn of the fallacy of the  conducted within the framework of  X belongs, for instance, the Balkans.
              widely held belief about FLT that by  student exchange programmes. The  The model suggested by Byram and
              giving learners greater insight into  authors reported cases of  Zarate - reciprocity and student ex-
               another way of life will automatically  English-German, French-English and  change - can only be partially implied
              lead to raising their awareness. How-  French-German exchanges.  here, for there are many languages
              ever, we ought not to lose sight of the                          (so-called small) which are not taught
              fact that awareness does not equal to  However,what hasnot been taken into  at schools in Europe.
              ’understanding’ (Byram, Morgan   account by them is what happens to  b) Do Y’s stereotypes about A, B,C
              1992:18).Alllearnersaddress the dis-  stereotypes when a foreign language  ... Zhave anyimpact on Xand towhat
              covery of a foreign culture with atti-  is learnt. Is the old lot replaced with a  extent?
               tudes and knowledge which isempiri-  newone? Or does the acquisition of a  This is a very interesting question and
              cally constructed through their own  new bunch of stereotypes equal to  the answer to it is positive. Very little
              culture.It followsfrom this thatsocio-  ’multiculturalism’? This is something  has been written about the mediating
              culturalinstruction inforeign language  that has to be investigated within the  role that the language Y, especially if
              teachingdoes notstart’from zero’, but  framework of second language acqui-  it has the status of the international
              has to deal with these preestablished  sition /learning. The other issue I am  language.The language Ycan besaid
              conceptsof theforeignworld (bitsand  goingto raise hereconcernstakinginto  to have a positive role-it establishes a
              pieces of information, personalexpe-  account interrelations and interplay  contact between the culture X and
              rience,generalization andstereotypes,  betweenstereotypes in two languages.  other cultures (A, B or C) and with-
              prejudices, aversions or preferences,  The problem is obviously very com-  out it such a contact would be very
              etc.) in the individual learner’s mind  plex and merits an in-depth analysis.  difficult or even impossible. On the
               (Byram, Zarate,1997:44). Easysolu-  In the remaining part of the paper I  other hand, there is a danger that the
               tions are not readily available, but  shall focus on possible ways in which  learners of the language Y may sim-
               there may be a chance in attempts at  stereotypesof twolanguages/cultures  ply adopt Y’s stereotypes about lan-
              widening people’s horizons, in help-  (X and Y) may interact.    guages and culturesthey have noother
              ing people toacquire an international                            contact with. A very good example is
              outlook. In these studies, the authors  a) X has auto-stereotypes  thecaseof the Balkans,which entered
              advocated the introduction of socio-  b) X has stereotypes about Y  many other languages through Eng-
              cultural competence in language  c) Y has auto-stereotypes       lish as a metaphor for cultural back-
              learning and teaching.They define it  d) Y has stereotypes about X  wardness.
              ascapacity tofulfill the role of cultural  e) X’s attitude of to Y’s stereotypes
              intermediary between one’s own cul-  about X                     Suggested approach in the
              ture and the target culture, including  f) X’sattitude to Y’sauto-stereotypes  classroom:
              situations of conflict. To acquire this  g) Y’s attitude to X’stereotypesabout
              competence,one has to possess knowl-  Y                          Students have to be sensitized to the
              edge of the interpretative discrepan-  h) Y’ sattitude to X’sauto-stereotypes  problem of stereotyping. This can be
              cies between the two cultural systems                            achieved by encouraging comparison
              and capacity to identify and take ac-  The relations rangingfrom a-d already  of the learner’sown word and the for-
              count of auto-stereotypes conveyed by  exist; those presented from e-h are
               theforeign community, and alsoof the  only possible outcomes. This is not to

              6
   2   3   4   5   6   7   8   9   10   11   12